BMW I5 Edrive40 M Sport 2024 vs Mercedes-AMG E-Class AMG E53 4m+(hybrid) 2025

Q: Which is more fuel efficient, the I5 or E-Class?

The I5 uses 15.9-18.9 kWh/100km l/100km and the E-Class uses 9.2 when hybrid battery discharged / 25.L/100km on the combined cycle. The E-Class is the more fuel-efficient choice. In real-world conditions with a mix of highway and urban driving, actual figures will be slightly higher.

Q: Which has more power, the I5 or E-Class?

The I5 produces 250 kW and 430 Nm of torque while the E-Class delivers 430 (opt 450) kW and 750 Nm of torque. The E-Class is the more powerful option.

Q: What is the price difference between the I5 and E-Class?

The I5 starts from R1 812 000 and the E-Class from R2 518 425. The I5 is cheaper by R706 425 at this variant level. Final on-the-road pricing varies by dealer and specification.

Q: Which has a higher towing capacity, the I5 or E-Class?

The I5 has a braked towing capacity of 1500 Kg and the E-Class can tow 2100 Kg. Always verify towing limits in the owner's manual before hitching a trailer.

BMW I5

Edrive40 M Sport

From R1 812 000

View Full Specs →

Mercedes-AMG E-Class

AMG E53 4m+(hybrid)

From R2 518 425

★ Our Pick

View Full Specs →

At a Glance

Power

250 kW

430 (opt 450) kW

Torque

430 Nm

750 Nm

Fuel

15.9-18.9 kWh/100km l/100km

9.2 when hybrid battery discharged / 25.L/100km

Towing

1500 Kg

2100 Kg

0-100 km/h

6.0 s

4.0 (opt 3.8) s

Engine

electric cc

2999 cc

Choosing between the BMW I5 and the Mercedes-AMG E-Class is one of the most common decisions car buyers in South Africa face. The BMW I5 delivers 250 kW while the Mercedes-AMG E-Class produces 430 (opt 450) kW. On fuel, the I5 returns 15.9-18.9 kWh/100km l/100km while the E-Class uses 9.2 when hybrid battery discharged / 25.L/100km — important in a market where fuel prices change monthly. Pricing starts at R1 812 000 for the I5 and R2 518 425 for the E-Class. Both vehicles have their merits. The right choice depends on your priorities: fuel economy, performance, towing ability, safety features or total cost of ownership. This comparison covers every specification available so you can make an informed decision.

Performance

Power Output

250 kW

430 (opt 450) kW

Torque

430 Nm

750 Nm

0-100 kph

6.0 s

4.0 (opt 3.8) s

Top Speed

193 Km/h

140 Km/h

Engine & Drivetrain

Engine Capacity

electric cc

2999 cc

Engine Layout

—

inline

Cylinders

—

Fuel Type

electric

petrol-electric hybrid

Forced Induction Device

—

turbocharger

Transmission

automatic

Number of Gears

Drive Wheels

rear

all

Full Time 4x4

—

✓ Standard

Fuel Economy

Fuel Consumption Average

15.9-18.9 kWh/100km l/100km

9.2 when hybrid battery discharged / 25.L/100km

Fuel Tank Capacity

81.2 kWh l

60 litre + 21.2 kWh l

CO2 Emissions

182 when hybrid battery charged / 23 comg/km

Dimensions

Length

5060 mm

4965 mm

Width

1900-2156 mm

1902-2065 mm

Height

1515 mm

1472 mm

Wheelbase

2995 mm

2971 mm

Ground Clearance

154 mm

—

Kerb Weight

2130 DIN / 2205 EU Kg

2315 DIN / 2390 EU Kg

Doors

Seats

Load Volume

490 l

370 l

Towing & Payload

Towing Capacity

1500 Kg

2100 Kg

Load Capacity

610 lkg

530 lkg

Safety

ABS

✓ Standard

EBD

✓ Standard

Brake Assist

✓ Standard

Stability Control

✓ Standard

Traction Control

✓ Standard

Airbag Count

8 (opt 10)

Driver Airbag

✓ Standard

Passenger Airbag

✓ Standard

Side Airbags Front

✓ Standard

Curtain Airbags

✓ Standard

Features & Tech

Air Conditioning

✓ Standard

Climate Control

✓ Standard

Cruise Control

Optional

✓ Standard

Adaptive Cruise Control

Optional

✓ Standard

Bluetooth

✓ Standard

Satellite Navigation

✓ Standard

Reversing Camera

Optional

✓ Standard

Park Distance Rear

✓ Standard

Park Distance Front

✓ Standard

Sunroof

Optional

Heated Seats

✓ Standard

Keyless Entry

✓ Standard

Tow Bar

Optional

Alloy Wheels

✓ Standard

Warranty & Service

Warranty Period

2 vehicle / 8 battery

Warranty Distance

unlimited vehicle / 100000 battery Km

unlimited vehicle / 160000 battery Km

Service Intervals

service interval indicator

The Verdict

Which Wins?

Overall Winner

Mercedes-AMG E-Class

3 / 4 categories

Performance

E-Class

Fuel Economy

E-Class

Value

Practicality

E-Class

Pros & Cons

BMW I5

+Lower starting price (R1 812 000)

-Less power than rival (250 kW vs 430 (opt 450) kW)

Mercedes-AMG E-Class

+More powerful engine (430 (opt 450) kW)

+Higher towing capacity (2100 Kg)

-Higher starting price

Frequently Asked Questions

Which is more fuel efficient, the I5 or E-Class?

The I5 uses 15.9-18.9 kWh/100km l/100km and the E-Class uses 9.2 when hybrid battery discharged / 25.L/100km on the combined cycle. The E-Class is the more fuel-efficient choice. In real-world conditions with a mix of highway and urban driving, actual figures will be slightly higher.

Which has more power, the I5 or E-Class?

The I5 produces 250 kW and 430 Nm of torque while the E-Class delivers 430 (opt 450) kW and 750 Nm of torque. The E-Class is the more powerful option.

What is the price difference between the I5 and E-Class?

The I5 starts from R1 812 000 and the E-Class from R2 518 425. The I5 is cheaper by R706 425 at this variant level. Final on-the-road pricing varies by dealer and specification.

Which has a higher towing capacity, the I5 or E-Class?

The I5 has a braked towing capacity of 1500 Kg and the E-Class can tow 2100 Kg. Always verify towing limits in the owner's manual before hitching a trailer.

Should I buy the I5 or the E-Class?

It depends on your priorities. If fuel economy matters most, check the L/100km figures above. If you need towing capacity, compare the towing ratings. For day-to-day South African driving - load shedding runs, potholed roads, school runs and highway commutes - consider ground clearance, service network coverage, and total cost of ownership including insurance and maintenance. Use the spec tables above to compare every detail before making your decision.

Also Consider